Archive for October, 2009

Fatal Accidents

Friday, October 30th, 2009

Statistics have just been released by the Health and Safety Executive to show that the number of fatal workplace injuries is at its lowest since records began. The number of workplace deaths decreased nearly a quarter this year compared to last.

There has also been a significant reduction in the number of people injured at work.

It is gratifying to see that responsible employers are now taking health and safety seriously.

However, there are still far too many who totally disregard health and safety law which puts their workers at risk. More often than not it is the everyday things like lifting a heavy box or slipping on a wet floor which cause the most problems. These problems can be easily remedied by employers with a little thought which will spare their workers months or even years of pain and suffering.

Nimrod – Airworthiness Sacrificed

Thursday, October 29th, 2009

October hasn’t been a good month for the MOD, with the official report into the Nimrod crash by Charles Haddon-Cave QC following on from the Harrogate Puma Inquest.  I was interested to see the concentration on this concept as we are just about to start a paper trail on airworthiness on the Puma aircraft.

I first came across Charles in the Manchester air crash 1985 where he acted for Pratt and Whitney and I subsequently instructed him to represent the families of the victims of the British Midland crash at Kegworth 1989 at the Inquest into that crash.

Whilst Charles’s commercial and international pedigree is beyond doubt he is also seen the human cost of systemic and cultural failures. I thought it was interesting that he likened the organisational causes to those of other disasters such as the Herald of Free Enterprise in 1987.

The naming of the ten individuals whom he blamed for the major roles in connection with the lack of fire safety in the Nimrod is highly unusual in my experience. However corporate culture is always driven by individuals and it is right that those who make the major decisions are held accountable whether they be within the MOD, within its major defence contractors or its regulators and auditors. QinetiQ were there to monitor the aircraft as independent advisors and I am reminded that the Coroner in Harrogate thought that the audit by MOD Standards and Evaluation Unit shortly before the August 2007 incident was a missed opportunity. 

It is of course tragic that it takes loss of human life to look at these matters with rigour.

Patient organisation raises concerns over care

Thursday, October 22nd, 2009

I have been reading in the news today that the National Patient Safety Agency has raised concerns over the standard of care afforded to patients in administering oxygen. The organisation says it has been highlighted to 300 complaints from patients and their families, including 44 deaths, where defective equipment has apparently lead to patients receiving substandard care. In addition, complaints have been raised against NHS staff for poor monitoring of oxygen levels, resulting in either too much or too little oxygen being administered, the consequences of which can be grave.

Frequently, certain sections of the press and indeed the National Health Service Litigation Authority, criticise Claimant solicitors for bringing cases against NHS Trusts in the first place, but these such incidents and others recently reported (see my previous blog entries), do nothing to dissuade those who have been injured unnecessarily from considering legal action. Indeed, what other recourse do they have?

As I have always said, the majority of the services and care provided through the NHS is of enviable quality, but ultimately, these occurrences need to be eradicated, whether that be through better training or the provision of suitable equipment.

Service PTSD

Tuesday, October 20th, 2009

Colonel Stuart Tootal has a double spread in the Independent today saying how his initial sceptism of PTSD has long gone.  He refers to the rescuers of Mark Wright GC being men he led and knew well.

We all met at the Inquest a year ago in Oxford.  I’m glad he refers to the Mark Wright Project and the work of other charities in this area but he’s right that the number of soldiers returning with this illness will grow another resource issue for the NHS + MOD.

Click here to read the article in the Independent

Report highlights poor out of hours GP care

Friday, October 2nd, 2009

The Care Quality Commission has published an interim report into the quality of out-of hours GP care run by some Primary Care Trusts. It has highlighted one example of deficient care provided to a patient who was given ten times the usual dosage of a painkiller resulting in his death.

Out of hours care is vital, when patients are taken ill and need to speak to, or be seen by, a GP. However, this should not mean that the patient should expect any less standard of care just because they need to see their GP out of normal working hours, for example at the weekend. The out of hours service alleviates pressure on Accident and Emergency departments, who patients may turn to if they are unable to see their GP, or such services as NHS Direct (which really exists for a signposting service and general guidance). Therefore it is all the more important that patients should be given the same level of care and be confident in the advice given, as they are with their GP.

The report has highlighted the lack of scrutiny by some PCTs in monitoring the standards provided by some private companies, and it is therefore of paramount importance that more stringent auditing is implemented.